Losing a tooth is a BIG deal when you’re little. As a parent, you know that the Tooth Fairy’s visit can either be a magical memory or a mad dash at midnight when you realize you forgot… again.
Don’t worry! You don’t have to be Martha Stewart to make it special. If you’re looking for creative Tooth Fairy ideas or just something simple that won’t leave glitter all over your house, I’ve got you covered.
Here are 15 genius Tooth Fairy ideas that are fun, unique, and easy enough for even the busiest parent to pull off!
This post contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no cost to you. See our disclaimer for more.
15 Brilliant Tooth Fairy Ideas (That Are Totally Doable)
1. A Tiny Tooth Fairy Note
Write a teeny-tiny note from the Tooth Fairy congratulating your child! Print a small, mini-message that mentions something specific your child did, like brushing their teeth really well lately, being brave at the dentist, or keeping their room clean.
Or grab these personalized letters handwritten to your child from the Tooth Fairy.
Bonus tip: Sprinkle a little “fairy dust” (aka glitter) on the paper if you’re feeling fancy.
2. Tooth Certificate
Make the lost tooth extra special by leaving an official Tooth Fairy certificate. You can find free printables online or make a simple one yourself with a gold star sticker.
3. Tooth Fairy Pillow
Use a little pillow to put the lost tooth in. It makes it MUCH easier for the Tooth Fairy to grab the tooth without waking up your light sleeper.
Pro Tip: Put the lost tooth in a small bag before putting it in the pillow. This makes it easy to get out of the pillow pocket at night and ensures the tooth doesn’t get lost.
4. Tooth Fairy Receipt
Leave behind a tooth fairy receipt card, listing the payment amount and a little description (“Excellent quality! Very clean!”). It’s silly, simple, and kids LOVE it.
5. Special Tooth Fairy Money Ideas
Instead of a regular bill, leave a $2 bill, a gold dollar coin, or some fun foreign currency. Even folding an everyday dollar bill into a fun shape feels way more magical!
Learn how to make an Origami money tooth with this video tutorial.
6. Tooth Fairy Door
Install a small tooth fairy door on the wall or baseboard in your child’s room. It’s a charming way for the Tooth Fairy to visit every time a tooth is lost!
7. Fairy Footprints
Use a washable ink pad and your pinky finger, a small Barbie shoe, or an action figure to make tiny “footprints” on a nightstand, windowsill, or a note. It’s a magical touch that’s surprisingly quick and easy. (Glitter works too if you don’t mind the mess!)
8. Tiny Gifts
Instead of cash, you can leave a small toy, a book, a new toothbrush, a printable coupon book, or even a tiny fairy-themed trinket. Bonus points if it encourages good dental habits!
Feeling crafty? Try these DIY dairy-dust pendant necklaces. You make them all at once and keep them on hand and ready for the next lost tooth!
9. Glitter Money
There are some fun and legal ways to create glitter money for a magical Tooth Fairy surprise without damaging real bills.
- Lightly mist a dollar bill with water and dust with a little loose glitter.
- Put the bill inside a sparkly envelope or a glittery little bag.
- Lightly mist the air above the dollar bill with glitter hairspray so a tiny shimmer settles on it.
Pro tip: You could even tell your child that “the magic dust disappears once human hands touch the money”. That way, any glitter that falls off feels like part of the magic!
10. Glow-In-The-Dark Magic
Leave behind a glow-in-the-dark ceiling star or a set of star wall stickers. Tell your child it’s a magical keepsake from the Tooth Fairy’s visit. Your child can collect them as they lose their teeth.
11. Tooth Fairy Door Hanger
Use a Tooth Fairy door hanger to make tooth pick-up and drop-off a breeze. No need to tiptoe into their room and risk waking them up! It’s the perfect solution for light sleepers and keeps the magic alive without the stress.
12. Magical Tooth Fairy Box
Make a special Tooth Fairy box for your child to store their lost teeth and tiny treasures. Decorate a small wooden or cardboard box with paint, stickers, and glitter. Add a secret code or lock for extra fun.
Grab a pre-made tooth box to use for easy tooth access, too.
13. Tooth Fairy Story Time
Build the excitement before bedtime by reading a fun tooth fairy story together. Books like The Night Before The Tooth Fairy or How to Catch The Tooth Fairy spark imagination and anticipation, making your child even more excited for the magical visit to come.
14. Last-Minute Tooth Fairy Note
Forgot until you’re halfway to bed? Scribble a quick note from the Tooth Fairy on a sticky note and pop it under the pillow. A little “Oops, I was running late from Fairyland!” makes it feel intentional!
Or write a note from the Tooth Fairy in the form of an IOU so they can trade it in for a fun experience gift, an ice cream cone, or some other kind of special treat!
For fun proof the Tooth Fairy visited, snap a photo of your sleeping child. Use the I Caught the Tooth Fairy app to add a magical image of the Tooth Fairy to it. It’s instant evidence she was there!
15. Tooth Fairy Memory Book
Create a Tooth Fairy memory book where you can document each tooth lost and the accompanying stories. Each page can include a picture of the tooth, the date it was lost, and a little note about the experience.
Quick Tips For Tooth Fairy Success
- Keep emergency supplies handy: A few dollars, coins, envelopes, glitter pens, and notes tucked away in a drawer are lifesavers when a wobbly tooth finally falls out at bedtime.
- Set a reminder on your phone: Seriously. Tooth Fairy magic is real, but so is parental exhaustion.
- Don’t stress: If you ever forget, just say the Tooth Fairy got caught in traffic or it was a busy tooth day. Kids are surprisingly forgiving when magic is involved.
Wondering What to Do With Baby Teeth?
There’s no single right answer. It really depends on what feels meaningful or practical for your family. Here are some common and creative options:
- Save Them as Keepsakes: Some parents keep a small collection of their child’s baby teeth in a keepsake box or a cute tooth storage kit.
- Let Them Go: If keeping them feels strange, it’s perfectly fine to quietly discard the tooth after the Tooth Fairy visit. Many parents do this!
- Preserve for Science: Some emerging science suggests that baby teeth might be valuable later for stem cell research. There are professional services that can preserve teeth for this reason, but it’s expensive and not something everyone chooses to do.
What’s Next?
Get the best family connection and routine content sent straight to your inbox. (Plus free printables!) Sign up below for free!
Don’t forget to pin these Tooth Fairy Ideas To Pinterest
